Controversy has erupted following remarks by Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav of the Allahabad High Court, who described certain Muslims using the term “Kathmullah,” a word widely regarded as derogatory. Justice Yadav’s comments, captured in a viral video, have been criticized for perpetuating stereotypes and targeting the Muslim community.
Referring to “Kathmullahs,” Justice Yadav stated, “The word may be inappropriate, but I have no hesitation in saying it because such people are harmful to the country. They incite the public and hinder the nation’s progress. Such individuals must be cautious.”
He further remarked, “Our (Hindu) children are tolerant and kind because they chant mantras and study Vedas, but their (Muslim) children cannot be expected to be compassionate as they witness animal slaughter.”
These statements have sparked widespread criticism, with legal experts and activists questioning the impartiality of the judiciary.
Critics argue that such remarks undermine the principles of justice and neutrality expected from members of the judiciary.
“Judges must rise above personal biases and uphold the Constitution’s values. Statements like these harm the judiciary’s credibility and set a dangerous precedent,” said a senior legal expert.
Civic groups, legal associations, and political leaders have condemned the remarks, demanding a thorough investigation into the matter. Several organizations have written to the Chief Justice of India, calling for action to safeguard the judiciary’s integrity.
“This is not just an isolated incident but a breach of judicial ethics. Such remarks erode public trust in the judiciary,” said a representative of a legal advocacy group.