The special court of NIA in Kochi granted bail to two students, who were arrested for alleged Maoist links in November last year and were facing charges under UAPA.
Allan Shuhaib, 20, a law student , and Thwaha Fazal, 24, a journalism student, were arrested in Kozhikode by local police and charged under Sections 38 and 39 of UAPA and Section 120B of IPC. The second accused was also charged under Section 13 of UAPA. Later, the case was handed to the NIA.
While releasing Allan and Twaha, the special Judge Anil K Bhaskar said, “there is no allegation by the prosecution that the accused conspired to do any specific terrorist act.
“It appears to me that even though the prosecution was able to establish the first postulate of section 38 and 39 of UAPA that the accused had associated with and supported the Maoist organisation, it is doubtful whether the prosecution has made out a prima facie case regarding the second postulate that the affiliation and support rendered by the accused to the banned organisation were done with the intent to encourage, further, promote or facilitate the commission of terrorist activities.
In other words, the petitioners were able to bring out a rational and reasonable doubt on the question of prima facie case.”
After observing the scribbling diary of the accused as evidence of Maoist links, the court said “a provocative thought ipso facto does not prove preparation for a crime”
The court observed that the petitioners have no criminal background and that the prosecution was not able to point out a single evidence wherein the petitioners have resorted to violence.
The court also quoted the verdicts of other courts that had granted bail to persons charged under UAPA.
Referring to a verdict of Bombay High Court, the NIA court said, “A number of persons are influenced and get attracted towards Maoist philosophy. It is impossible to hold that all such persons are to be treated as members of terrorist organisation”